Schlich Ltd +44(0) 1903 717001 info@schlich.co.uk
Back

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has answered the question of whether the Enforcement Directive (2004/48) prevents Member States from providing in their national legislation the possibility of awarding punitive damages in IP cases.

Background

The Polish Regional Court had awarded damages for a much lower sum than that which was claimed by the claimant, noting that an award of punitive damages in respect of an infringed IP right would likely contravene Article 13 of the Enforcement Directive, despite having provision in Polish law.

Decision

Upon referral by the Polish Supreme Court, the CJEU answered the question in OTK vs SFP, C-367/15, of whether the Enforcement Directive prevents Member States from providing in their national legislation the possibility of awarding punitive damages in IP cases.

Citing Recital 26 of the Enforcement Directive, the CJEU noted that the wording of Article 13 should be interpreted as “not entailing an obligation on Member States to provide for ‘punitive’ damages” and not as a prohibition on introducing such a measure.

In an attempt to clarify the purpose of the Enforcement Directive, the CJEU further cited Recital 10 which states that “the objective of the Directive is to approximate legislative systems so as to ensure a high, equivalent and homogeneous level of protection in the internal market”.

Conclusion

Despite providing good news for IP right holders, the CJEU Decision in C-367/15 potentially puts a question mark over the harmonising strength of the Enforcement Directive. This is mainly because the “homogenous” level of protection referred to in Recital 10 is, in fact, heterogeneous if each Member State has the ability to determine the level at which damages can be punishing on the defendant.

 

 


Our articles are for general information only. They should not be considered specific legal advice, which is available upon request. All information in our articles is considered to be accurate at the date of publishing.

最近公司动态

Update: Schlich Walks to the EPO!

Update: Schlich Walks to the EPO!

Working in kilometres (we are, after all, European Patent Attorneys), we have managed to walk approximately 530km and are officially more than halfway to Munich!  If we were to physically walk to...

read more
Schlich walks to the EPO!

Schlich walks to the EPO!

After the New Year’s confetti has been swept away, the biscuit selection boxes are demolished and everyone has settled back into the nine to five, it’s likely that some of our New Years resolutions may have already taken a backseat.

read more